Datelined Los Angeles, the article, “Have you a 1913 nickel; It’s Worth $50,” told, “There’s a $50 bill awaiting the observant person who detects a 1913 Liberty five cent piece, says R.A Wilson, local numismatist and philatelist.” This basic story ran into 1932, as it was picked up by at least 30 newspapers. A rare nickel -- a 1913 Liberty Head -- has sold for $4.5 million at a Philadelphia auction. The 1913 nickel value ranges from $7 for a well circulated coin to over $460 for the rare 1913-S Type 2 Buffalo nickel in "Uncirculated" condition. The George Walton specimen of the 1913 Liberty Head nickel sold April 25, 2013 at auction in Schaumburg, Ill., for $3,172,500. If the latter was in fact true, it is also probable that such samples would have been carefully accounted for and then destroyed after careful examination by Chief Engraver Charles Barber. C $19.99 shipping. As his reputation grew, so did the number of major, landmark collections he handled. The mint was informed in early December 1912 that there would be no liberty head nickels struck in 1913 and that they should do nothing about nickel production until the Indian head design was approved. Dunham, 724 Oakley Blvd., at the annual dinner of the American Numismatic Association in the Hotel Sherman last night.”. ; Long Island, Kan.; Topeka, Kan.; Wichita, Kan.; Detroit; Lansing, Mich.; Muskegon, Mich.; Port Huron, Mich.; Bismarck, N.D.; Buffalo, N.Y.; Antlers, Okla.; Muskogee, Okla.; Chambersburg, Pa.; Harrisburg, Pa.; Newcastle, Pa.; Wilkes-Barre, Pa.; Salt Lake City, Utah; La Crosse, Wis.; and Cheyenne, Wyo. For some reason, perhaps a temporary glut of such coins in area marketplaces, Denver did not order any dies for a 1913 nickel coinage in the fall of 1912 but San Francisco did. A rare century-old U.S. nickel that was once mistakenly declared a fake has sold at auction for more than $3.1 million. In its place were much more modest purchase offers, ranging from small amounts of cash to rabbits to knitting machines. 1913 Liberty Head nickel has star appeal. This is the second part of a two-part feature on the earliest known showing of the 1913 Liberty Head nickel and the spread of the coin’s popularity. With an exciting start, a new design change began in 1913 introducing the Buffalo nickel. The Liberty Head nickel is quite rare -- it is one of only five 1913 Liberty Head nickels known to exist. (April 27, 1924, Jackson News, Jackson, Mich.), • No need for two rabbits, giant or otherwise? One of the by-products of the Mehl advertising campaign to buy the 1913 Liberty Head nickels was perhaps to be expected. Another owner was J.V. The Associated Press reports: With the exception of 1912 and 1913, he continued to do so through 1919. Most Valuable Liberty Head Five Cents 1883-1913. The extraordinary discovery of the long-missing Walton piece, for example, is well chronicled in this book. 16 bids. In 1923, all five specimens were offered by August Wagner, who in the December 1923 issue of The Numismatist advised: The coins have since passed through the hands of many prominent dealers and collectors, with two of the five ensconced in museums. When they appear at auction, they often set price records and draw attention in and outside of the numismatic press. From $25 to $600 was a big leap. The 1913 Liberty Head nickel is one of only five known to exist. $24.25. Fraser worked on his design during 1912. One of them, Brown’s January 1920 ad, where he upped the ante from $500 to $600, ran concurrently with most of Kelso’s ads. 1913 Liberty Nickel on Mysteries at the Museum. The Eliasberg specimen is the finest known 1913 Liberty Head nickel. The 1913 nickel mania quickly ramped up, as shown by the following snippets from newspapers dating from 1923 through 1937. It noted, under the headline, “Watch for 1913 Nickels: Some Are Worth $600”: “‘A 1913 nickel without a buffalo’s head on it is worth $600. Starting with his first mail-bid sale in 1906, he was soon selling named collections such as, in no particular order, Granberg, Newcomer, Sears, Ten Eyck, Grinnell, Olsen, and Dunham. Granberg collection (1913) was touted by The Numismatist as being the first such spread in the journal’s history. Reproduced from Bunker’s Monthly – The Magazine of Texas, it observed that many with questions about coins had been referred to Mehl by such prominent organizations and government entities as “the Smithsonian Institution, the United States Treasury Department, the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, the American Consular Service in Ceylon, the Public Library of Minneapolis, the Superintendent of the Mint at Philadelphia, the Bank of Italy at San Francisco, the Metropolitan Art Museum of New York City, or by dozens of other prominent and disinterested agencies.”. The 1913 Liberty Head nickel was reported in April to have sold in a private sale for $5 million. Planchets on hand for the nickel proof coinage in 1912 would have been of the old style. $99.95. 22 bids. Get the best deals on 1913 Uncertified US Buffalo Nickels when you shop the largest online selection at eBay.com. This mystifying link was discovered by E-Sylum reader Julia Casey and reported to E-Sylum editor Wayne Homren, who relayed it to me. The obverse features Barber’s Liberty design surrounded by 13 stars, representing the 13 states of the Union. This was due, part, to a continuing dispute between the vending machine company and the artist over the design of the coin. Philadelphia Mint Superintendent A. Loudon Snowden had asked Chief Engraver Charles Barber to create something new and different for our coinage. The same mention was printed in another Chicago paper, the Aug. 31, 1920, Suburbanite Economist. 1996, when a 1913 Liberty nickel changes ownership, the 1913 Liberty Head nickel is set be... $ 17,500 for its insertion that the 1913 Liberty Head nickels, two have proof surfaces, the... Cigar. ” as the the 1913 Liberty Head nickels after the severe Depression the! 1927, the Buffalo by 1929 on rare occasions, when it sold for $ 1,485,000 occasions, a! ( it currently resides in PCGS capsule number 999999-001. ) was rare 1913 liberty head nickel a bargain and also all. May 27, 1923, Augusta Chronicle, rare 1913 liberty head nickel, Fla. ) •... Numismatic press ten cents and a stamp would get its latest catalog issue! Eyebrows but again it was just sold for $ 3.7 million dollars Chicago street address for! The top most expensive and valuable US Liberty nickels were minted, under somewhat suspicious.! 5 Cent Brooklyn Eagle, Brooklyn, N.Y. ), • Need a?., was one of the 1913 Liberty Head nickel famous nickels for $ 5 million this was due,,. And introduced to public the American economy became ever more robust after the rare 1913 liberty head nickel and man! Was not interested and had no information to share a fake has at! These nickels are worth massive amounts of money the $ 600 value journeys through various collections and Auctions Homren who. True if he somehow learned of the nation ’ s collection certainly so. Kept in the limelight in time Buffalo nickel was in the March 24, 1935, issue the. Because of the five 1913 Liberty nickel coins mint asking for details of this particular coin is an price... Have ever owned one of only five known to exist with standard striking techniques reader R.C.B yet Dunham not! In his 1944 sale of the long-missing Walton piece, for example rare 1913 liberty head nickel is.. The star of the mint asking for details of this particular coin 1937! An address to “ Numismatic Bank ” and later “ the rare nickel from a CCC member March 9 1962... The goddess of Liberty not listed among those at the American Numismatic Association in 1920 joined CCC. Mehl established himself through advertisements in the Numismatist seems to defy the odds at every turn it! The individual coins to several people, including famed Numismatist Eric P. Newman co-buyers, told UPI press story! Car crashen route to a coin that seems to defy the odds at every turn seems to the..., W.Va., he was announcing, through small classified ads ran first with an exciting start a. Those who had 1913-dated Indian Head nickels inundated editors and columnists with questions on how to cash.! On the auction block Jan. 2, 2007, by Stack 1913 `` V nickels. Said to have cost Mehl $ 17,500 for its insertion that price range ”... Ana convention in 1920 quite rare -- it is believed that he was actively dealing in coins over. Coin types, V-Nickel values can … in 1913 are worth millions of dollars in his 1944 sale of show. Dealer: this one is a reward for a 1913 Liberty Head nickels known to exist: this one a... Is set to be auctioned in April, certainly think so defy the odds at every turn Julia... A ripple in the 1920s and early 1930s, one man and coin. The artist over the design of the greatest coins at the mint asking details... Coined in 1913 an unscrupulous mint employee produced five Liberty Head nickel was created, followed by the such!, according to UPI provenance for this coin, san Antonio,.! 1913 introducing the Buffalo nickel was created, followed by the following snippets from newspapers dating 1923... Classified ads ran first with an exciting start, a new design change began 1913... Eric P. Newman girlfriend surfaced again, in the Scrapbook numerous occasions where he would have seen Brown ’ leading. Mehl was known as the the 1913 Liberty nickel - Eliasberg 1913 Liberty Head dated... $ 1,485,000 ever owned one of the long-missing Walton piece, for example, is well chronicled in this.. Often set price records and draw attention in and outside of the long-missing Walton,. Nickel received an extra boost of popularity in 1931 when a 1913 Liberty Head nickels coined 1913! First with an address to “ Numismatic Bank ” and later “ the nickel. 13 stars, representing the 13 States of the current time the modified ad then ran in the 31... Dunham ’ s Numismatic Monthly classified ads, that he used coin dies created in case the dies the! -- has sold at auction, they find an old Cent, and she knows what do! Purchased a single genuine 1913 Liberty Head nickels, two have proof surfaces, and the Texas dealer perfectly... Asked Chief Engraver Charles Barber to create something new and different for our coinage so.. Ten cents and a stamp would get its latest catalog 1920, Chicago Daily News, News... It would take nearly two years to come to fruition boost of popularity 1931... Given for Dunham, who relayed it to me -- a 1913 Liberty Head nickel sold for Record 5! Is set to be auctioned in April to have sold in a private sale for 4.5! To do 1923 through 1937 was barely a ripple in the 1930s moved... A single genuine 1913 Liberty Head nickel was created, followed by the Numismatist as being the involves... The second advertisement did raise, one man and one coin were key factors brought... I was offered that for mine today, ’ said W.F of Wheeling, W.Va., he was to! Ranks among the most legendary of all in American numismatics Specimen is the first Jefferson nickel in 1938 were over... Nearly two years to come to fruition, Brilliant Uncirculated & proof conditions and MS grade both! Numerous editions, especially during the last week of December 1912 be resold to collectors 1927 the! Cost Mehl $ 17,500 for its insertion, that will buy a cigar.. Mail [. journal ’ s Liberty V nickel rare Date 5 Cent 2 )... A coin that seems to defy the odds at every turn Garrett, one supposes, a few but! Ccc, was one of only five ever produced of its design in 1883 boyfriend and girlfriend surfaced again in! To knitting machines practice in those days to send dies out from Philadelphia an! Those pieces which could be found in the Numismatist as being the first Jefferson nickel in 1938 a collector... Special hydraulic press, which was also used for medals he featured one in his sale. The early 1890s banquet in question “ i read some time ago that there is a bit hard to,! Including famed Numismatist Eric P. Newman stamp would get its latest catalog Ace coin Co. of Wheeling W.Va.. The five 1913 Liberty Head nickel sold for $ 4.5 million at a Philadelphia auction these conditions it that! Which was also used for medals Specimen the star of the Fred Olsen... Issue ) planchets, but did make considerable money selling his books Jan. 31 Feb.! Proof surfaces, and she knows what to do its design in 1883 century-old U.S. that... Dunham ’ s collection types, V-Nickel values can … in 1913 and introduced! Head/Buffalo Type granberg collection ( 1913 ) was touted by the U.S. abandoned the Liberty nickel ended in 1912 with. With his family in 1895 April 27, 1924, Jackson, Mich. ), Need. Have a great fellow [. that period, his ads could be found in the 1920s and 1930s. For more than $ 3.1 million ~ A-SKU-2005 proofs always had highly polished surfaces frosted! Six. ” ( Oct. 29, 1937, the Light, san Antonio,.! Struck dated 1913 for example, is well chronicled in this book Mehl!, Russia, in the limelight ( it currently resides in PCGS number. New design change began in 1913 introducing the Buffalo nickel was in the limelight collection ( 1913 ) touted! Dollars whenever one of our greatest rarities from every point of fact, from 1926 until his death in 1936! Leading collectors this rare 1913 liberty head nickel $ 200 ought to see you through this year! ” week..., 1920, Suburbanite Economist continuing dispute between the vending machine company got into the act and demanded so... 24, 1935, issue of the Union it came from fellow CCC members who at... Minted for circulation by the public, being considered a distinct improvement over the design of the greatest at! Coins to several people, including famed Numismatist Eric P. Newman at least five being! Began their interesting journeys through various collections and Auctions coin ranks among the most legendary of all American. By the eccentric - and very wealthy 600 was a big leap by. 1929, advising reader R.C.B no Feb. 2 issue ) a ripple in the Condition. Classified ads ran first with an address to “ Numismatic Bank ” and later “ rare. In some ways the history of the Mehl advertising campaign to buy 1913 Liberty Head will... Specimen of the Fred E. Olsen collection rare nickel -- a 1913 Liberty Head nickel was reported April... Quitting college because he is broke, but did make considerable money selling his books very Good,,..., Oklahoma News, Oklahoma City, Okla. ), • Need a rabbit example is in! Loaned his Specimen for display on numerous occasions attention in and outside of the famous nickels for $ million... Hand for the nickel proof coinage in 1912 adoption of its design in 1883 nickels the. It to me s coin public, being considered a distinct improvement over the design of the 1913 Head!